07 November 2019

Reviewer minta Cite Papers

Sekarang ni timbul satu trend baru, apabila kita terima komen daripada Reviewer, Reviewer tersebut minta/propose kita cite beberapa papers (lebih kurang 10 papers).
“This Manuscript is good, but even better if the authors could add these papers….”
“Please add these papers into your Introduction…”

Jika kita teliti senarai papers tersebut... kita dapati ia menjurus kepada 1 nama, jadi inilah Reviewer kita (yang sepatutnya Reviewer adalah anonymous/nameless).

Tapi Alhamdullilah ada editor yang bagus:
"EDITOR REPORT: It is not mandatory to add references suggested by the reviewers. Authors may wish to add them if they are relevant but it will not affect the outcome of the review if they are not added."

Saya pun tak mahu cite paper not related!

Tujuan utama mereka buat mcm ini ialah nakkan byk citation... maklumlah nak apply Prof A soon kikiki...

Moral of Citer, tak perlulah buat benda Unethical mcm ni. Kalaulah kita ni Tok Bomoh yang hebat... rumah atas bukit, ceruk ladang getah...
disebabkan kita HEBAT, tak perlu suruh, ORANG AKAN CARI!!

No comments:

Post a Comment