Ada banyak jenis examiner tesis; 1. buka tesis untuk cari kesilapan sebanyak mungkin, 2. buka tesis untuk improve tesis daripada kesilapan sebanyak mungkin dan 3. buka tesis hanya pada hari viva (tak buat apa-apa sebab tak sempat) :)
Yeah that's different kind of examiners. Since examiners are human being so it is totally depend on who you are. If you are "killer", nawaitu nak hentam student je kejenya, memang bukak tesis utk cari kesilapan semata. Dah nama pun draft tesis, of cause la ade kesilapan di sana sini. Sebab apa masih ada mistakes? (1) Yg tulis tu student..dah nama pun student so maksudnya dia sedang dalam proses belajar lagi! (2) student pun human being jugak, nobody is PERFECT!(3)may be SV xtgk pun tesis tu, hanya mengharap writting seorang student. So kalau ye pun byk mistakes, tegur la secara baik, jgn jd KILLER. Betulkan niat, being PROFESSIONAL & igt tanggungjawab yg diberikan.
Examiner yg second ni plak baik hati sgt, abis semua bende nak di improvekan. That's good...such a "golden heart" examiner. Susah nak jumpa examiner camni. Examiner jenis ni paham tanggungjawab dia & berusaha utk improve tesis supaya student dapat belajar dgn lebih byk. Sebab kalau satu2 tesis tu hanya dibaca oleh SV & student sendiri, mungkin mistake tu xnampak. Examiner may be drpd bidang yg berbza sikit (tapi masih dlm skop), so examiner may have different point of view or the better way to present the tesis. That's fantastic!
Spesis examiner yg last ni yg plg teruk sy rasa. X amanah dgn kerja. Impossible x sempat baca walau 2-3 helai pun. Lebih malang lagi, examiner spesis yg ke-3 ni, dah la xbaca tesis lps tu main ikut examiner yg "killer" tu utk sama2 blasah student although die sendiri xtau hujung pangkal. Main tokok tambah serangan maut drpd examiner killer je. Kdg2 tu soklan yg x logik pun leh kluar akibat xbaca tesis. Pastu dgn bangganya pulangkan tesis yg BERSIH tanpa sebarang conteng pun. Kesian student. Bagai jatuh dihempap tangga! Udah la tesis xde feedback from examiner, kena pula jwb soklan yg x masuk dek akal. But not everyone is BAD! Ade jugak examiner yg mengaku secara jujur yg dia xsempat nak go through the whole tesis akibat beban kerja hakiki yg melampau, so more question will be asked based from the presentation. At least, student dapat some feedback..xbyk but useful.InsyaAllah student dpt terima & faham kesibukan examinernya although tesis yg dipulangkan masih BERSIH tanpa sebarang CONTENG!
Bottom of the line: Student should be responsible for the thesis, check everything bkn main print & submit je...and avoid doing it in rush. On the other hand, examiner should be responsible as well, nawaitu kasi betul & being professional enough =)
Salam,
ReplyDeleteYeah that's different kind of examiners. Since examiners are human being so it is totally depend on who you are. If you are "killer", nawaitu nak hentam student je kejenya, memang bukak tesis utk cari kesilapan semata. Dah nama pun draft tesis, of cause la ade kesilapan di sana sini. Sebab apa masih ada mistakes? (1) Yg tulis tu student..dah nama pun student so maksudnya dia sedang dalam proses belajar lagi! (2) student pun human being jugak, nobody is PERFECT!(3)may be SV xtgk pun tesis tu, hanya mengharap writting seorang student. So kalau ye pun byk mistakes, tegur la secara baik, jgn jd KILLER. Betulkan niat, being PROFESSIONAL & igt tanggungjawab yg diberikan.
Examiner yg second ni plak baik hati sgt, abis semua bende nak di improvekan. That's good...such a "golden heart" examiner. Susah nak jumpa examiner camni. Examiner jenis ni paham tanggungjawab dia & berusaha utk improve tesis supaya student dapat belajar dgn lebih byk. Sebab kalau satu2 tesis tu hanya dibaca oleh SV & student sendiri, mungkin mistake tu xnampak. Examiner may be drpd bidang yg berbza sikit (tapi masih dlm skop), so examiner may have different point of view or the better way to present the tesis. That's fantastic!
Spesis examiner yg last ni yg plg teruk sy rasa. X amanah dgn kerja. Impossible x sempat baca walau 2-3 helai pun. Lebih malang lagi, examiner spesis yg ke-3 ni, dah la xbaca tesis lps tu main ikut examiner yg "killer" tu utk sama2 blasah student although die sendiri xtau hujung pangkal. Main tokok tambah serangan maut drpd examiner killer je. Kdg2 tu soklan yg x logik pun leh kluar akibat xbaca tesis. Pastu dgn bangganya pulangkan tesis yg BERSIH tanpa sebarang conteng pun. Kesian student. Bagai jatuh dihempap tangga! Udah la tesis xde feedback from examiner, kena pula jwb soklan yg x masuk dek akal. But not everyone is BAD! Ade jugak examiner yg mengaku secara jujur yg dia xsempat nak go through the whole tesis akibat beban kerja hakiki yg melampau, so more question will be asked based from the presentation. At least, student dapat some feedback..xbyk but useful.InsyaAllah student dpt terima & faham kesibukan examinernya although tesis yg dipulangkan masih BERSIH tanpa sebarang CONTENG!
Bottom of the line: Student should be responsible for the thesis, check everything bkn main print & submit je...and avoid doing it in rush. On the other hand, examiner should be responsible as well, nawaitu kasi betul & being professional enough =)
~white rose~